1868: A Review of "Little Women"

This is a drawing of a blank, open journal and a quill.

This review of Little Women appeared in a Massachusetts newspaper in 1868, both praising and criticizing the author's tale. 

 

Miss Louisa Alcott's "Little Women" is a girls' book of quite another sort.  The name describes its field well. They are not children but "little women" whom she portrays; her characters, Meg, Jo, Beth and Army, are girls with the instincts of womanhood strong and active, but without the simplicity of childhood. The restless and confused period which divides the child from the woman is here represented under four different aspects, and with a great variety of domestic incident. The four sisters are natural in their sayings and strivings, because they are drawn from life, - and yet there is much that would seem unnatural, could we forget the age and character of the four. They vary from ten to sixteen years old, at the outset of the story, and are the daughters and only children of Mr. March, a chaplain in the Union army, who leaves his family poor at home, while he follows the camp, summer and winter, and at last falls sick and lies in the hospital for months. His family in the meantime play the drama of life around the fireside at home; the mother directs the affairs of the household, while the four daughters act plays together, write stories, edit newspapers, go to parties, fall in love, quarrel and make up again, stroll in the woods, sail on the river, make new acquaintances, and do all those thousand things that lively girls find to busy themselves about. And there is much pleasure in threading the tangled story, from end to end, and a good deal of interest felt in the fortunes of each sister, and all her adventures, at home and abroad. In the details of the piece the great talent of Miss Alcott is shown to advantage; she manages scenes better than most storytellers; but her plot is defective, and does not do itself justice. What most impresses one in reading the book is the wealth of resources at her command, within the limited sphere of her story. There are scarecly any but purely domestic events, for the war and its incidents count for but little; yet these household adventures are wonderfully varied and rich; such as children will not much care for; but they will attract the girl and boy have an inkling of the world beyond the children's horizon. The book is published by Roberts Brothers, and sold by Bridgman. It is illustrated from drawings by Miss May Alcott, which have not had full justice done them by the engraver. The same is true of the illustrations in Dotty Dimple. It is a pity, the artist's idea in all the sketches was a good one. 

 

Source:

"Books for Girls," The Springfield Daily Republican (Massachusetts), October 21, 1868. Accessed through Newspapers.com

Topic(s):