1852: "Is...the book is a mere fiction?"
In 1852, a Massachusetts newspaper published a criticism of the new book Uncle Tom's Cabin and then an editorialized rebuttal.
Uncle Tom's Cabin.
The most effective statement in Mrs. Stowe's catalogue is untrue, and cannot be true, - to wit: the selling mother and child to separate purchasers - as by the statute books of the State this very thing is prohibited by an enormous fine. Now, why, in fair dealing with her dupes, does she not tell them this is a fiction, and is meant to prejudice the public mind, and to make her book racy and saleable? She does not do so: but I will ask, what credit or influence can such a book claim when we find an inaccuracy such as the above at the outset? Is it not proof that the book is a mere fiction?
Correspondence of the New York Express
The writer of the above is very, very ignorant. If there are laws against the separation of parents and children, we know them to inoperative. That the general public sentiment of the South is against such separations, we are aware, but children and parents are separated. We remember a beautiful mulatto girl who was carried from Kentucky to a Southern city, by a Slave trader. Five or six persons tried to purchase her. They took her to their families, where, notwithstanding the threats of the trader, and with a heroism worthy all admiration, she persisted in telling her simple story of separation from a son that she said was beautiful - the child of her former master's son - and declared that she never could be happy or contented away from him [her son]. The consequence was that not one family would buy here, and the scoundrel who had her in charge was obliged to take her back to Kentucky, to get rid of her. The feeling of the community was her protection, and not the laws. If Mrs. Stowe has no sins to answer for more than that indicated above, she will escape scatheless.
Source:
"Uncle Tom's Cabin", The Springfield Daily Republican (Massachusetts), September 14, 1852. Accessed through Newspapers.com